2.1 KiB
id, aliases, title, tags, dg-publish
| id | aliases | title | tags | dg-publish | ||||||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| mike-holts-illustrated-guide-to-electrical-estimating | _Mike Holt's Illustrated Guide to Electrical Estimating_ |
|
true |
Mike Holt's Illustrated Guide to Electrical Estimating
Commentary on holt_2023_estimating.
Goodreads Review
Mike Holt's Illustrated Guide to Electrical Estimating, like all of Holt's printed content I'm familiar with, is a masterclass in construction education presentation featuring attractive design, and plenty of detailed illustrations. The bones of a great estimating textbook are present, it has a compelling topic organization and progression, however the content does not deliver on the promise.
The text treats estimating like an invariable set of procedures: (1) get the documents (2) do the takeoff (3) do the closeout (4) send the bid; if there's ambiguity in the documents, then send an RFI.
The reality of the industry is far messier than Holt would have you believe.
What do you do when RFI's go unanswered? Drop the job?
In fact, the text suggests that all assumptions ==are bad==
I was compelled by my employer to purchase this book along with several others of Holt's as part of my apprenticeship curriculum. I can't shake the feeling that this entry was intended to pad out the course to four years.
Goodreads Review Scratch
Holt's tone is undeservedly authoritative and principled.
It refuses to acknowledge the questions of complexity that the content itself begs. "Never make assumptions"
Many topics are grossly oversimplified, or omitted entirely (subcontractor RFQ process)
This book is far too large in scope to lack the detail it does.
It feels designed for those unlikely to need or understand its topics, except it is far too long for a layman's introduction.
If there will ever be a book to be what this one could not, I don't think Holt would be the one to write it. The group's content is very "teach to the book" which is exactly what you want for contractor exams, but not practical for estimating methodology.